Sexual counseling and breast cancer: a review of 10 studies suggests benefits for intimate life, but the evidence is still very uncertain.
Why sexuality after breast cancer is a clinical issue
Breast cancer is the uncontrolled growth of abnormal cells in breast tissue. According to the global estimates reported in the study, in 2022 it accounted for 11.6% of all newly diagnosed cancers, the second most frequent in the world. Progress in diagnosis and treatment has brought five-year survival to around 90%. As a result, more and more women live for a long time with the effects of their therapies, and quality of life after the disease has become a central question. Among these effects, sexual problems are among the most common and persistent. An earlier meta-analysis of 19 studies on 2,684 women with breast cancer, cited by the authors, estimated that 73.4% had sexual dysfunction. The cause is often the treatment itself: surgery, chemotherapy, radiotherapy and endocrine therapy (medicines that counteract the action of hormones) can cause treatment-induced menopause, dryness and thinning of the vaginal lining, and changes in body image. Desire, arousal, lubrication, orgasm, satisfaction and the onset of pain are affected, but so are intimacy, emotional well-being and the couple's relationship. Despite this, sexual health is still rarely addressed in routine oncology care. Clinical guidelines recommend psychosocial or psychosexual interventions for the sexual problems of people with cancer, and counseling is one of the most accessible tools.What "model-based" sexual counseling is
Model-based counseling is not a free conversation: it follows a structure defined in advance, which helps the practitioner bring problems to light and tailor the intervention to the needs of each woman. The studies included in the review used six different approaches:- PLISSIT, the most widely used (four studies): the name sums up four increasing levels, namely giving permission to talk about sexuality, providing essential information, offering specific suggestions and, if needed, referring to specialized sex therapy;
- BETTER, a model that organizes communication about sexuality in the cancer setting;
- Good Enough Sex, a couple-centered approach, used in two studies with group sessions;
- the self-regulation model, self-efficacy theory and the theory of planned behavior, which work on beliefs, confidence in one's own abilities, and behaviors.
How the study was designed: is sexual counseling for breast cancer surgery effective?
This is a systematic review with meta-analysis: the researchers searched for all the studies published on a precise question and combined their results with statistical methods. The protocol had been registered before starting, a safeguard against the temptation to change the rules while the work is under way. The search, carried out on 10 March 2025 in five scientific databases, retrieved 356 records; after duplicates were removed and the full texts were read, two independent reviewers selected 10 studies. Seven were randomized controlled trials (RCTs), in which participants are assigned by lot to the group receiving counseling or to the control group; three were controlled studies without randomization. In all there were 779 women, 417 in the intervention groups and 362 in the control groups, with samples ranging from 18 to 120 people. Nine of the ten studies were conducted in Iran and one in Brazil, between 2016 and 2025. The control group received usual care or no specific intervention. The programs also varied widely: from one to three individual sessions, four weekly group meetings of 90-120 minutes, a six-week package delivered through a messaging app, up to an educational program with two meetings a week for 12 weeks. Assessments ranged from the end of the intervention to 12 weeks. There were two outcomes. Sexual function was measured with specific questionnaires, mostly the Female Sexual Function Index, which assesses desire, arousal, lubrication, orgasm, satisfaction and pain. Overall sexual life was a broader category that grouped related but different measures: satisfaction, sexual behavior, sexual quality of life and function. Because each study used different scales, the results were converted into a common measure, the standardized mean difference (indicated by the letter g): it is 0 if there is no difference between the groups and grows the better the treated group does compared with the control group. Finally, the certainty of the evidence was assessed with the GRADE method, which classifies confidence in the results as high, moderate, low or very low.Results on the effectiveness of sexual counseling for breast cancer
On overall sexual life (10 studies, 729 women), model-based counseling showed a favorable and statistically significant effect compared with control, with a g of 1.86. On sexual function (8 studies, 616 women) the result was similar, with a g of 2.11. The total analyzed is lower than 779 because, in the two studies with three groups, the additional intervention group was excluded so as not to count the same control women twice. These numbers must be read with care. One study, based on the Good Enough Sex model, had an unusually large effect: removing it from the calculation, the effect on overall sexual life falls from 1.86 to 1.12, while remaining significant. As a result, a substantial part of the size of the effect depends on a few studies. On sexual function, by contrast, excluding one study at a time did not change the picture: no single study on its own explained the differences between the results. The most unexpected finding concerns PLISSIT, the most studied model. In the studies that used it, the effect was not statistically significant either on overall sexual life (g 0.60) or on sexual function (g 0.59). The authors point out that this does not prove that PLISSIT is ineffective: there are too few studies to draw a conclusion either way. The analyses by assessment time found the largest effects at 6-8 weeks, still significant at 12 weeks. On overall sexual life the effect was already significant within 4 weeks of the end of the intervention; on sexual function, in that first interval, it was not. The authors warn against reading these differences as a trend over time, because each interval included different studies.How far it can be trusted: the limitations of studies on sexual counseling for breast cancer
The authors' final judgment is clear: the certainty of the evidence is very low for both outcomes. There are three main reasons.- Very different results across studies. The heterogeneity index (I²), which measures how much results vary beyond what chance can explain, exceeded 95%. This happens because models, number of sessions, duration, questionnaires and the characteristics of the women changed a great deal from one study to another.
- Geographical concentration. Nine of the ten studies come from Iran: the cultural context in which sexuality is discussed and the organization of care may not match those of other countries.
- Mixed outcomes. "Overall sexual life" brings together related but not equivalent aspects, so the pooled estimate is an exploratory synthesis, not the measure of a single thing.
What it means for women with breast cancer
The first message is that sexual problems after breast cancer are frequent and linked to treatment: they are neither a secondary issue nor a reason for embarrassment. Talking about them with the oncologist, the gynecologist or the reference nurse is the step that makes it possible to recognize them and, when needed, to be referred to a specialist. The second is that structured counseling seems able to help, but today it is not known how much, nor which model works best. The authors themselves write that the data are not enough to establish a reliable clinical benefit or the superiority of one approach. As a result, the program should be chosen together with one's own care team, taking into account personal needs, the couple's relationship and the resources available at the center.What research still needs
The authors call for larger randomized trials, conducted in different countries, with standardized counseling protocols, common questionnaires and a follow-up longer than 12 weeks. Only then will it be possible to compare the models with each other and understand whether any benefit lasts over time.Message for healthcare professionals
The study in brief. Systematic review with meta-analysis with a registered protocol of 10 controlled studies (7 RCTs, 3 non-randomized; 779 women; 9 studies in Iran) on sexual counseling based on theoretical models (PLISSIT, BETTER, Good Enough Sex, self-regulation, self-efficacy, planned behavior) compared with usual care or no intervention, with follow-up of up to 12 weeks. Results| Comparison | Outcome | Effect | Certainty of evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model-based counseling vs control | Overall sexual life | Statistically significant improvement, large but unstable in size g 1.86; 95% CI 0.94–2.77; k = 10; I² 95.9% | Very low (GRADE) |
| Model-based counseling vs control | Sexual function | Statistically significant improvement g 2.11; 95% CI 0.94–3.28; k = 8; I² 97.1% | Very low (GRADE) |
| Model-based counseling vs control, at 12 weeks | Overall sexual life | Effect still significant g 2.16; 95% CI 0.92–3.39; k = 7; I² 96.4% | Exploratory subgroup, not assessed with GRADE |
| Model-based counseling vs control, at 12 weeks | Sexual function | Effect still significant g 2.49; 95% CI 0.67–4.31; k = 5; I² 97.8% | Exploratory subgroup, not assessed with GRADE |
| PLISSIT vs control | Overall sexual life | No significant difference g 0.60; 95% CI −0.29–1.50; k = 4; I² 87.6% | Exploratory subgroup, not assessed with GRADE |
| PLISSIT vs control | Sexual function | No significant difference g 0.59; 95% CI −0.26–1.43; k = 3; I² 80.5% | Exploratory subgroup, not assessed with GRADE |
Hedges' g calculated on post-intervention scores with random-effects models; k = number of studies; I² = heterogeneity between studies. Excluding the study with the largest effect, the estimate for overall sexual life falls to g 1.12 (95% CI 0.44–1.80; I² 93.0%).
Limitations- Extreme heterogeneity (I² above 90% in the main outcomes), persisting when excluding one study at a time; protocols not standardized for frequency, duration and delivery mode.
- Indirectness: 9 of 10 studies conducted in Iran, with limited applicability to other cultural and healthcare settings.
- The "overall sexual life" outcome combines non-equivalent constructs; search limited to five databases and to the abstract field; publication bias cannot be ruled out with few studies.
In practice. Structured sexual counseling is a reasonable way to explore sexual problems, offer support and refer to a specialist when needed, but the evidence has very low certainty, the effect estimates are unstable and no model has proven superior to the others: its adoption should be assessed case by case, according to the patient's needs and the center's resources.
Bibliography
- Yalav O, Gezer D, Taylan S. Effects of Model-Based Sexual Counseling on Sexual Function and Sexual Life in Women with Breast Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Healthcare (Basel). 2026;14(20):3516. doi:10.3390/healthcare14203516 PubMed

Medical Doctor, Medical Oncology resident




